Match of the Year

Winner: The Undertaker vs. Triple H – WrestleMania “End of an Era” Match

Newcomer of the Year

Winner: Ryback

LOL Moment of the Year

Winner: The Rock throws John Cena items into Boston Harbor

Superstar of the Year

Winner: John Cena

Comeback of the Year

Winner: Jerry “The King” Lawler

“Tell me I did NOT just see that” – (The Most Shocking Moment of the Year)

Winner: Kofi Kingston walks on his hands to avoid elimination at The Royal Rumble

Betrayal of the Year

Winner: Big Show knocks out John Cena at WWE Over the Limit

Insult of the Year

Winner: John Cena to Dolph Ziggler & Vickie Guerrero: "You're the exact opposite. One enjoys eating a lot of nuts and the other is still trying to find his."